Why did Ebby (who carried the message to Bill W) struggle to get permanently sober?

Lois Wilson shared her insights into Ebby in her biography, Lois Remembers, and stated that while Bill wanted sobriety with his whole soul, Ebby appeared to want just enough sobriety to stay out of trouble. In addition, Lois said, ‘Beyond that crucial visit with Bill, Ebby seemed to do very little about helping others. He never appeared really to be a member of AA. After his first slip, many harmful thoughts seemed to take possession of him. He appeared jealous of Bill and critical, even when sober, of both the Oxford Group and AA.’ Lois felt that it was important that AAs know why Ebby was not considered the founder of AA. Ebby carried the message to Bill, but he never followed it up with the years of devoted action needed to develop the AA programme.

Another AA who had known Ebby in Texas said that, ‘Ebby held a deep resentment for Bill, Dr Bob, and others, because he felt he was more the founder of what was to become AA than anyone else’. In the author’s opinion, this resentment may be the reason for his repeated ‘slips’ in the programme.

Ebby also had the idea that he needed the right woman and an ideal job in order to stay sober. The implication is that if he didn’t have the perfect woman and the perfect job, he couldn’t stay sober. And he didn’t stay sober. AA members know that sobriety has to be sought without any conditions, that we have to be ‘willing to go to any length to get it’ and that ‘half measures availed us nothing’.

Some of Ebby’s own letters bring to mind Lois’s observation noted earlier, that Ebby seemed to be ‘around’ AA, but never really ‘in’ it. Typical correspondence from AAs devotes substantial discussion to the AA programme and the application of the Steps to their own lives. Ebby’s letters avoid these topics and are significant for what they don’t say. In 1954, Bill wrote that Ebby now, ‘shows more signs of really joining AA than ever before.’ The implication is that Ebby had shown less commitment to the AA programme before then, but even at that time, there were still substantial doubts about his sincerity.

Earlier, in 1947, his sister-in-law received a letter from Ebby, and she wrote back suggesting that the answer to his problems was to devote himself to helping others and then continued, ‘But as I read your letter this thought is far from your mind, and you are again concerned with the petty and material affairs of your surroundings and the bickerings and by-plays of your associates, with the thought still deep in your mind that you have been persecuted and discriminated against by others, while the real facts might well be that it is your own ego that is at fault.’

Our problem as alcoholics centres in our minds, in having an entire psychic change as a result of taking the actions set out exactly in the Twelve Steps. It is said in the rooms, ‘If you do what we did, you’ll get what we got.’ Ebby was unable, for whatever reasons, to put the AA programme of action into his life on a regular basis.

All of his life, Ebby was overshadowed by the recognition and success of his father and grandfather and in his own generation, by the accomplishments and respect given to his older brothers. This may have developed in him a sense of ‘never being good enough’ so familiar to alcoholics. It is also likely that his privileged childhood accentuated the sense of self-importance and self-focus that the AA programme requires us to deflate at depth.

If Ebby had been recognised as the founder of the AA programme, it would have given him respect and recognition far surpassing anyone in his family. After Bill received the message of recovery from Ebby, he devoted the rest of his life to helping other alcoholics. If Ebby had been willing and able to take similar actions of love and service, he would have been a co-founder with Bill Wilson. But he would not, or could not, do the day-to-day work with others needed to bring AA into a concrete reality.


Rather than realistically looking at his own shortcomings in establishing AA, Ebby wallowed in resentments, the greatest obstacle to sobriety and the number one killer of alcoholics. Perhaps Bill was thinking of the example of his sponsor, Ebby, when he wrote the many strong statements in the Big Book condemning resentments. For whatever the reasons, Ebby never seemed to give himself completely to the simple programme of Alcoholics Anonymous.

Comments